Does Open Rate still matter?

Article author
Kirk Bentley

Short answer: yes, but not the way it used to. An open used to mean “a human saw this.” Now it means “something loaded the images.” Sometimes that’s your subscribers. Sometimes it’s a server in a data center, or increasingly, and AI bot. 

Here’s what changed, what it means for your numbers, and what to watch instead.
 

How open tracking works

Every email carries a tiny invisible image, called a tracking pixel. When that image loads, we count an open. This works great if you know a human is the one downloading the images. But due to changes that mailboxes have made over the last several years, we don’t know that for sure anymore.
 

What changed

Apple Mail Privacy Protection (2021–now)
If a subscriber uses Apple Mail and has MPP turned on, which most do, Apple downloads every image in the email as soon as it arrives, whether anyone reads it or not. That counts as an open. Apple also hides the subscriber‘s location and device. Apple Mail makes up a big share of opens for most senders, so this one change has a huge effect on your numbers.

Gmail’s image proxy
Gmail loads images through Google’s own servers and caches them. Gmail doesn’t fake opens the way Apple does, but it hides location and device data, and repeat opens often don’t register at all.

Yahoo and others
Several inbox providers route images through proxies. That hides who opened and where they were located when they opened. 

Security scanners and bots
This one really surprises people. Many workplaces, universities, and government offices run security tools like Microsoft Defender, Mimecast, and Proofpoint. These tools open emails and test the links before a human ever sees them. That can produce opens, and even clicks, within seconds of sending. If your list includes a lot of work addresses (board members, donors at corporate sponsors, school contacts), you’re likely seeing some of this.
 

How does it affect reporting?

  • Open rates look higher than reality
    Machine opens can make your campaigns look better than they are. A 61% open rate probably isn’t real. 
  • Location and device reports get fuzzy
    Proxies report the proxy’s location, not your patron’s.
  • Subject line A/B tests on opens are shaky
    When a chunk of your “opens” happen automatically, the winning subject line may just be the one that went to more Apple users.
  • “Engaged” segments based on opens are inflated
    Someone who hasn’t read your email since 2022 can still look like a superfan if you only look at opens.
  • Automations triggered by opens may fire for people who never opened
    If you’re using Workflows that trigger from opens, you might be sending a series to someone that never really opened.
     

So... do opens still matter?

Yes, but not for engagement. Use them as a trend line and a marker of long range performance. If there’s a sudden change in opens, that should get your attention.

  • Use opens as a signal
    A sudden drop in opens is still a useful warning sign. It can point to a deliverability issue, a bad sending day, or a list problem. Compare your own campaigns over time, not against industry benchmarks.
  • Don’t use opens to make decisions about individual people
    Don’t decide who gets removed, who counts as engaged, or who goes into a VIP segment based on opens.
  • Watch for opens or clicks that happen instantly after sending
    That’s usually a office mail scanner, not a superfan.
     

Metrics that matter

  • Clicks
    Still the most reliable sign of real attention and email engagement.
  • Conversions
    Ticket purchases, donations, registrations, and memberships. This is the real scoreboard, and it lives in your CRM and ticketing system. Make sure you’re using Google Analytics and/or source/promo code tracking on your links so you can track attribution accurately.
  • Unsubscribes and spam complaints
    These tell you when your content or frequency isn’t working.
  • Bounces
    List hygiene is critical. Keep your eye on bounce rate and keep it under 5%.
     

Move away from open rate focus

  • Build engaged segments around clicks and purchases, not opens.
  • Test subject lines on clicks or conversions
    Or think of open-rate tests as rough guidance at best.
  • Run re-engagement campaigns based on click and purchase history
    Someone who hasn’t clicked or bought in 12 months is worth a re-engagement campaign, even if they look like they’re opening everything.
  • Promote your preference center
    Subscribers who tell you how they want to hear from you are one of the best signals you can receive.
  • Reset expectations with leadership
    If your board loves open rate, help them fall in love with clicks and revenue instead.
     

The bottom line

Opens are still a helpful metric but not something to base your decision-making off. The metrics that pay the bills (clicks, purchases, gifts) are still the gold standard of reporting.